Why Were Celtic Denied A Penalty?

With questions over the consistency in refereeing decisions this season, Celtic have seen yet another example of inconsistency this afternoon against St Johnstone.

With Daizen Maeda seemingly destined to score, the Japanese winger’s effort was blocked by Luke Robinson, with the ball appearing to strike his arm in a clear denial of a goal-scoring opportunity.

Given the decision to award a penalty to Hearts at Tynecastle after the ball accidentally struck Tomoki Iwata, the St Johnstone defender went out of his way to stop Maeda’s effort in a deliberate act.

Despite VAR in place, the decision was no penalty, in yet another confusing decision by Scottish officials who have not covered themselves in glory this season.

Soccer Football – Scottish Cup – Quarter Final – Celtic v Livingston – Celtic Park, Glasgow, Scotland, Britain – March 10, 2024 Celtic’s Tomoki Iwata in action with Livingston’s Jamie Brandon REUTERS/Russell Cheyne

Put simply, if the defender doesn’t use his hand to block, Celtic score, and at 0-0, decisions like that could have cost Celtic the win today and ultimately the league title.

On another day, a decision like that would have been the talking point of the game, but with Celtic winning 3-1 in the end, the Hoops will take all the plaudits in a great display, with Kyogo Furuhashi and Nicolas Kuhn stealing the headlines.

Advertisement goes here

Advertisement goes here

Other stories

Celtic’s chaotic transfer window continues to come under heavy scrutiny, with

Celtic’s summer transfer window came to a frustrating and chaotic close,

Breaking news