A controversial research and development (R&D) tax credit scheme, designed to reward genuine advancements in science and technology, has landed several Scottish Premiership clubs in hot water—with Rangers, Dundee United, and Hibernian all taking advantage of the payouts. However, Celtic saw right through the proposal, knocking back the approach without a second thought.

CeltsAreHere understands that the consultancy firm behind the scheme pitched their offer to the Hoops, but they were told in no uncertain terms where to go. While some clubs were seeing pound signs, Celtic’s hierarchy clearly recognised the scheme for what it was and kept the club well clear of any potential financial or reputational risk.

The same can’t be said for Rangers, who banked £748,000 over four years through the scheme. The Ibrox side received £500,000 in the 2020/21 season alone, with smaller sums of £188,000, £26,000, and £34,000 in the preceding years. While there’s no suggestion yet that HMRC are knocking on the door at Ibrox, they’re certainly keen to recoup funds from clubs who might not have played by the rules.[SunSport]

Dundee United, who claimed £1.27m, have already been asked to repay up to £600,000. Their latest accounts reveal the situation: “The club have appealed against this and, with support from R&D tax experts, are engaging with the tax authorities to demonstrate that the qualifying R&D requirements were met.” Their advisors are on the hook for 20% of any repayment, which might soften the blow, but it’s still a sticky spot for the Tannadice club.

Hibernian, who received £1.28m, could also face further scrutiny. The scheme’s rules are clear—tax credits should only apply if the research benefits the broader public, not just a football club’s bottom line. It’s hard to see what sort of scientific breakthroughs were being made on some of Scotland’s training pitches, but some clubs do love a tax fiddle.

While Rangers and others scramble to justify their claims, Celtic’s decision to show the door to those peddling the dodgy scheme looks smarter by the day. The club’s straight-up approach has kept the focus firmly on football, with Brendan Rodgers’ side pushing for success on all fronts.

In a time when some rivals are facing awkward questions from HMRC, Celtic’s stance is a reminder that integrity matters—and that not every offer is worth entertaining.