Looking back now, it’s clear Brendan Rodgers made a big mistake in the Scottish Cup final against Aberdeen this afternoon. Kasper Schmeichel started in goal ahead of Viljami Sinisalo, and it cost Celtic dearly. Hindsight might be a luxury, but in this case, the warning signs were there for all to see.

Schmeichel, who had picked up a shoulder injury during the international break, didn’t look yet back to his best. Despite that, Rodgers trusted the experienced keeper for the final. But it was a move that didn’t work.

Schmeichel made a massive mistake during normal time, allowing Aberdeen to equalise and send the game into extra time. When the game went to penalties, he failed to save any of the spot-kicks.

On the other hand, Sinisalo had been in top form. While Schmeichel was injured, the young Finn stepped up. He played well during his run in the team, including an impressive performance at Ibrox against Rangers. That run of form made it all the more surprising when he was dropped for the final.

In total, Sinisalo has played eight games this season and kept four clean sheets. That’s a solid return for a young goalkeeper still making his way. He showed confidence, sharpness, and good handling during those games—something Schmeichel lacked in the final.

Rodgers had a tough decision to make, but choosing experience over form didn’t work out. Schmeichel’s performance showed he wasn’t at his best. Meanwhile, Sinisalo had done everything asked of him and more.

Cup finals are often decided by small moments. In this one, Celtic’s choice of goalkeeper played a major role in the final result. Sinisalo deserved the chance to stay in the team. Rodgers took a risk, and it backfired.

It’s a moment that will be hard to forget. For Schmeichel, it’s an afternoon he’ll want to move on from quickly. For Sinisalo, it’s a missed chance to shine in a cup final. And for Rodgers, it’s a decision that will be talked about for a long time, with supporters set to call for Sinisalo to be given more starts next season.