The value of a player is often measured by their on-pitch performances. However, there are other factors that contribute to a player’s worth, particularly in the context of a team’s overall composition and strategy.
This is the case for Celtic defenders Anthony Ralston and Stephen Welsh.
Ralston and Welsh have been the subject of much debate among Celtic fans, with many hoping to see them leave this summer. However, there are compelling reasons for retaining both players, which extend beyond their individual abilities.
Firstly, both Ralston and Welsh are on relatively low wages compared to other squad players who would potentially replace them. In an era of escalating player salaries, this financial aspect cannot be overlooked. Retaining Ralston and Welsh could allow Celtic to allocate resources more effectively, perhaps investing in other areas of the squad and could even see the club bring in the ‘marquee’ signing that the fans are so desperate to see.
Secondly, and perhaps more importantly, Ralston and Welsh help Celtic meet the Champions League requirements. Celtic must reserve eight places for Celtic/Scottish trained players. Currently, this quota is met by McGregor, Taylor, Turnbull, Welsh, Bain, Ralston, Forrest, Johnston, and McCarthy. Removing Ralston and Welsh from this list would leave Celtic with two empty slots, effectively reducing the squad size for the Champions League.
It’s likely that McCarthy, who is on the list, will also depart this summer.
The B-Team players are registered on another list due to their age.
While Ralston and Welsh may not be the most glamorous players in the squad, they have proven that they can do a job for Celtic when called upon. Their understanding of the club’s culture and their commitment to the team’s cause are assets that cannot be quantified.
Sometimes players just have to ‘get it’ and the pair really do ‘get it’.
The value of Ralston and Welsh to Celtic extends beyond their on-pitch performances. Their relatively low wages and their contribution to meeting Champions League requirements make a strong case for their retention. While it’s understandable that fans want to see continual improvement in the squad, it’s important to recognise the value of players like Ralston and Welsh, who provide depth, meet regulatory requirements, and embody the spirit of the club.
